Is your wipe really sporicidal?

Posted

7th December 2017

Products

Sporicidal disinfectant wipes are being used increasingly for tackling surfaces contaminated with C. difficile spores in hospitals. A wide range of ‘sporicidal’ wipes are coming onto the market. However, concerning published data shows that some wipes marketed as being ‘sporicidal’ do not have meaningful activity against spores when tested under controlled laboratory conditions. This blog outlines three key questions that you should be asking when a company comes to you with a ‘sporicidal’ wipe: is it plausible that the chemicals in the wipe will have sporicidal activity? Does the laboratory data provided by the manufacturer support their claims? Were the tests performed in a reputable, accredited laboratory? If the answer to any of these questions is no, then your wipe probably isn’t sporicidal and you should look for an alternative!

There is rapidly accumulating evidence that disinfectant wipes out-perform ‘bucket’ methods for disinfection. They are more convenient, assure the correct concentration of disinfectant, are safer for users, and make it easier to achieve an appropriate contact time. A particular challenge in hospitals is disinfecting surfaces that may be contaminated with C. difficile spores, or clinical areas that have been used to treat diarrhoea and vomiting where a pathogen has not been identified. Wipes with sporicidal activity can help to reduce the transmission of C. difficile in hospitals. So disinfectant providers have responded by developing a whole range of sporicidal wipes. The problem is that some of these wipes have very limited or no sporicidal activity. This blog aims to help users in negotiating a complex marketplace of sporicidal wipes using three simple questions:

  • Is it plausible that the chemicals in the wipe will have sporicidal activity?

We know from centuries of research that some chemicals, notably oxidising agents (for example peracetic acid, hydrogen peroxide and hypochlorites) have sporicidal properties when in the right formulation and at the right concentration. However, other chemicals do not have sporicidal activity, notably quaternary ammonium compounds even when combined with triamines, even though suboptimal testing methods, particularly when neutralising the agents may provide the apprearance of sporicidal activity. GAMA produce such a wipe and would never claim sporicidal activity.

  • Does the laboratory data provided by the manufacturer support their claims?
  • There is no current European standard test for sporicidal efficacy in the healthcare sector. In lieu of a more appropriate test, healthcare disinfectant manufacturers often use EN 13704, but a Joint Working Party from the Healthcare Infection Society (HIS) and the Advisory Committee on Antimicrobial Resistance and Healthcare Associated Infections (ARHAI) of the Department of Health England recommended that it requires significant modification to evaluate sporicidal activity in conditions reflective of a healthcare environment. Therefore, passing laboratory tests based on these Working Party guidelines should be regarded as the minimum standard for a sporicidal wipes to be used in healthcare settings.
  • Were the tests performed in a reputable, accredited laboratory?Even if the laboratory data tick all the right boxes and the wipe seems to exhibit sporicidal activity, it’s important to ensure that there is assurance that these data are robust and that the testing laboratory is accredited.Laboratories that state that they are ‘working towards’ ISO and UKAC accreditation are therefore not accredited. This is not to say that non-accredited labs are always inferior or inaccurate, as many well-respected University and Hospital research labs are not accredited. It’s just that laboratory accreditation is designed to ensure that standard tests are performed in a standardised way so that everybody can rely on the results.

GAMA has produced a Sporicidal Wipe based on peracetic acid. Peracetic acid has long been known to have sporicidal properties, the wipe has been tested using appropriate methods in independent, accredited laboratories and also in respected university laboratories. If you’d like to have some more detailed information on this issue, or you’d like to speak with an expert at GAMA (or we can put you onto an independent expert), please get in touch.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

Tags

Latest News

Products

Gloves Off: reducing unnecessary plastic waste during environmental cleaning and disinfection

In this blog, Dr Phil Norville discusses the momentum-gaining ‘Gloves…

Products

Gloves Off: Navigating SDS sheets and skin safety claims in environmental decontamination products

In this blog, James Clarke (Head of R&D, Science &…

Products

Help reduce staff sickness and improve air ventilation with Rediair

As the winter season approaches, concerns over staff sickness and…

Research

Moments that Matter: celebrating the fundamentals of infection prevention

To celebrate the fundamentals of infection prevention, we’re exploring the…