Quats vs. hydrogen peroxide vs. VRE


12th June 2017


A Dutch laboratory evaluation of four different disinfectant applied by either spraying or wiping has found that most are effective against key hospital pathogens. However, the hydrogen peroxide spray was ineffective against VRE, suggesting a problem with hydrogen peroxide stability. The study tested the ability of a hydrogen peroxide solution (branded a sporicidal), QAC, alcohol, and glucoprotamin to inactivate clinical isolates of VRE, K. pneumoniae, and A. baumannii. The products were applied as either a spray or wipe following a 1 hour contact time. All disinfectants achieved a >5 log reduction on the organisms tested, with the exception of hydrogen peroxide sprayed onto VRE. Now, hydrogen peroxide is very effective against enterococci, so I suspect that this illustrates a problem with instability of the hydrogen peroxide in the disinfecant formulation. It is also worth noting that the long contact time (1 hour) is not representative of the real world application of these products, where a 1 minute contact time would be more appropriate! This study provides further evidence that QACs (the key active ingredient of Clinell Universal Wipes) can be used to provide stable and effective disinfectant wipes.



Latest News


Gloves Off: Navigating SDS sheets and skin safety claims in environmental decontamination products

In this blog, James Clarke (Head of R&D, Science &…


Help reduce staff sickness and improve air ventilation with Rediair

As the winter season approaches, concerns over staff sickness and…


Moments that Matter: celebrating the fundamentals of infection prevention

To celebrate the fundamentals of infection prevention, we’re exploring the…


Tackling surface contamination is key to controlling Candida auris

Candida auris is a key emerging threat to healthcare facilities…